Most fantasy worldbuilding tips tell you to invent more — more maps, more factions, more lore. Johannes Grahmann's advice runs the other way: build less, but build it so you can walk through it. Johannes wrote his Master's thesis on the dwarf in modern fantasy literature, spent years reviewing games for Worldofwarcraft.de and Gameplane.de, worked on Albion Online, and today consults, edits and localises for game teams. We asked him for the five tips he would give anyone writing fantasy worlds — for games, novels, or interactive audio stories.
JG
This week's expert
Johannes Grahmann
Magister Artium in German & English Literature. Games Academy 2015/16. Works remote in localisation, editing and consulting. Contributed to Albion Online and several pirate-themed games; wrote game reviews and reports for Worldofwarcraft.de, Gamona.de and Gameplane.de. Ever since The Hobbit was read to him as a child, his focus has been fantasy worlds that weave in nature, animals, and the contrast between civilisation and seemingly untamed wilderness.
Tip 1 — Hook with identification points, then break the pattern
Games, novels and series all carry clichés and patterns their audience expects — and to a certain degree, you have to deliver on them. That is what identification points are: the familiar handholds that pull players, readers and viewers into a story. The real art is then not delivering 100% — playing with the possibilities instead, and creating unexpected actions and setups.
And this doesn't only mean the final twist. Smaller developments and traits in characters or plot beats early in the story can already deviate from the pattern, as long as the break isn't too severe. Take the well-worn example of the anti-hero, who of course becomes a hero in the end. As expected. But what if he doesn't? What if the anti-hero falls again — and then things happen?
Bringing a situation like that about slowly and coherently is a real challenge, Johannes admits — but it's also one of the best ways to surprise your audience and keep them gripped.
Tip 2 — Give every antagonist a motivation you could defend
Stay true to your story: be predictable in the small steps, but not in the larger arcs and turning points. And don't shy away from describing the negative, the bad, the outright evil in detail — wallow in it, even celebrate it. Villains written at arm's length stay cardboard.
Very few "evil" characters are evil out of conviction. EVERY one of them has their own inherent motivation for what they do — if not outright positive in their own eyes, then at least understandable.
— Johannes Grahmann
Letting the protagonist discover those motivations and backgrounds is a strong incentive at the start of a story — it gets the plot rolling. From that point on there is a personal bond with the events and with the antagonist, and the plot is grounded.
For the plot itself, Johannes works from the basic questions: Who? What? Why? Where? When? Answer them for every plot point, think through how the points interact with each other and with other threads, and the shape of the story stands. What remains is deciding how detailed you want it to be — which is effectively the choice between a Grimm fairy tale and a full-scale Song of Ice and Fire.
Tip 3 — Build a world you can walk through yourself
Johannes' core worldbuilding technique is physical: build a world you yourself walk through. Imagine moving through it and note what you see — the details, the different aspects, and the world as seen through the lenses of different characters, including ones completely uninvolved in your plot.
Then write short reports or sheets from their perspective about individual aspects of the world, and use them to bring out its quirks. If you want, expand those reports into small standalone stories — instant side content, grown straight from the world.
Take it slow, and don't reject any idea outright. Instead, check whether it fits the conditions that hold in your world — or how it would have to be adapted to fit. Then trace the consequences: on the world, on its inhabitants, on its creatures, on your characters, on the story as you imagine it. Then see whether the change feels better — and if it doesn't, roll it back. Don't be afraid to undo things, or to limit them in time within your world. A magical era that ended is worldbuilding too.
Tip 4 — Show character development in actions
For character work, Johannes recommends studying historical figures: their development, their actions, their traits, and what you can take from them. Real people are the richest source of contradictions that still feel coherent.
Then break your characters down to their fundamental motivations and behaviours — and show the character's development in the character's deeds. Show, don't tell. The oldest rule in the book, and still the one most fantasy writing breaks first.
Tip 5 — Hunt for the decisions that don't quite fit
In a good story there comes a point where things start to fall into place by themselves — you develop a feel for how each character acts. That feel is not the finish line. It's a tool: take it and challenge it. Look for decisions that don't quite fit, that rub against the grain. Those are the important beats — the decisions that shape a character. Those are the moments you're hunting for.
But be careful: they need to be well prepared, properly embedded and cleanly executed within the story and the character's development. And they must stay rare — a story made only of pattern breaks has no pattern left to break.
Especially interesting, for interactive stories most of all: choices introduced as a small action or interaction that later — inside the story and the world — turn out to have influenced or triggered major decisions. Those are always special moments, and they have to be crafted very precisely. Not-knowing is a key ingredient here: the audience shouldn't see the weight of a choice at the moment they make it.
Fantasy worldbuilding tips
Johannes Grahmann in five lines
- Hook with familiar identification points — then deliberately break the pattern, early and late.
- Give every antagonist a motivation that is at least understandable; let the protagonist discover it.
- Build a world you can walk through; write reports from the eyes of uninvolved characters to find its quirks.
- Break characters down to motivations and behaviours — and show their development in their actions.
- Hunt for the rare decisions that don't quite fit a character, and hide their weight until later.
Where Johannes' own strengths lie
Johannes describes himself as strongest in consulting on and revising other authors' texts, and in finding creative themes in collaboration with others. On the page, his favourite territory is where his fantasy focus began: nature and animal scenes, dreams, and magical experiences. He also prefers open endings and hints over hard resolutions — give readers a clear direction, but leave room for them to think the characters and storylines onward themselves. It frees far more creativity in the audience than it costs the writer, he says. It isn't always easy. It's worth it.
Johannes' favourite story
Tad Williams — Otherland. A grand epic, in Johannes' words, that plays through every variant of modern technology and its possible effects.
What he has worked on
Various games — Albion Online, of course, and several pirate-themed games — plus fantasy novels and short stories, YouTube videos, and years of game reviews and reports for Gameplane and Worldofwarcraft.de/Gamona.de. Today most of his time goes into consulting work.
The interactive audio story he wishes existed
The story of World of Warcraft, told properly as a narrative experience. There are already a few takes on it on YouTube — Johannes is a fan of Bellular, whose voice he calls an incredibly soothing experience when narrating WoW lore. A universe that size, made playable by voice alone, is exactly the kind of project interactive audio was built for.
About 5 Tips on Writing
A TWIST Tales series where writers and narrative designers share five tips, one voice, zero filler. Want to get featured with your best tips on writing?
Submit Blogpost Request