Kelly Bender and the Writing Advice I Did Not Want to Hear

Kelly Bender and the Writing Advice I Did Not Want to Hear

On this mission to become a better writer, I keep calling people who have already done the work — and hoping that one of them finally hands me the secret shortcut. Kelly Bender was the first person in this series to give me the writing advice I did not want to hear, very clearly and very repeatedly.

There is no shortcut.
— Kelly Bender

Kelly is a narrative designer, comic writer and game writer who came into games through a Ubisoft writing test after years in indie comics. He has written on Assassin's Creed Odyssey and Age of Mythology: Retold, and now teaches the craft through his own narrative-design bootcamp. He has done more reps than most people working in the field. So when he talks about how writers actually improve, it is worth listening — even when the answer is the most annoying one possible.

KB
This episode's expert
Kelly Bender
Narrative designer, comic writer, and game writer. Credits include Assassin's Creed Odyssey and Age of Mythology: Retold. Runs his own narrative-design bootcamp for writers breaking into games.

The shortcut doesn't exist

Naturally, I asked Kelly the important question: what is the one trick that turns me into a bestselling writer without years of pain, repetition, failure and effort? His answer was brutally simple. Not "there is kind of a shortcut." Not "there is a framework." Not "there is one mindset hack." Just: no shortcut. Deeply inconvenient for my strategy.

But the way he explained it was useful. Writing, in his view, is not about suddenly producing one masterpiece. It is about doing the reps. Small stories. Then bigger stories. Different genres, different perspectives, different structures. Not because every story will be good — but because each one forces you to become better. The goal is not only to improve the story. The goal is to improve yourself as a writer.

Small stories before big dreams

One thing I liked very much in Kelly's thinking is that he pushes against the fantasy of starting with your giant, life-defining masterpiece. His advice is almost embarrassingly simple: write one story. Give it a beginning, a middle, and an end. Then write another one.

He compared it to training for a marathon. Nobody decides to become an Olympic runner and starts with the final race. You train. You fail. You build stamina. You improve your technique. Then you do it again. That is the writing advice you resist for years before finally accepting it. It matters because many writers — myself included — are in love with the big vision: the great series, the huge fantasy world, the bestselling saga. Kelly's point was that those ambitions are useless if you have not built the practical muscles first.

The same goes for motivation. Kelly does not treat writing as a divine emotional state that either arrives or doesn't. He treats it like work you schedule. Sometimes that means drafting. Sometimes it means research, studying structure, building characters, networking, or learning how a real profession works so your dialogue sounds believable. All of it counts toward finishing. "Writer" is one of the few identities people claim without ever having been paid for it, trained for it, or finished anything substantial. Finishing is the filter.

What fantasy writers can learn from westerns

Toward the end of the call we got into westerns, and this became one of my favourite parts of the conversation. Kelly loves westerns, and what he pulls out of the genre is not aesthetics — it is focus. Westerns are stripped back. Fewer distractions. Simpler worlds. Rawer characters. Cleaner stakes. A cabin, a horizon, five riders in the distance — and suddenly you have tension without any of the usual machinery.

That was a strong reminder for me. In fantasy, we often hide behind scale — big lore, big maps, big external threats. Westerns show what happens when you remove all of the decoration and let character, space, danger, and human conflict do the work. Those are hard craft lessons that transfer cleanly from one genre to another.

What I'm taking from this one

This call was valuable mostly because it attacked my favourite illusion. I wanted a shortcut. Kelly gave me a process. Write. Finish. Try again. Get better. Repeat. Very annoying. Very useful. And I think that is why the conversation stayed with me — not because it handed me a trick, but because it reminded me that becoming good is not mysterious. It is just harder, slower, and more repetitive than most people want it to be. Kelly, thank you. I hated parts of this advice, which is usually a good sign — proof of honesty rather than another comfortable framework.

Writing advice
What Kelly Bender actually said
  1. There is no shortcut. Write, finish, try again, get better, repeat.
  2. Every story you finish is a rep that makes you sharper — writing is work you schedule, not a mood you wait for.
  3. Research, structure study, and character work all count toward the finished thing. Finishing is the filter.
  4. Pull lessons from genres that strip back: westerns do more with less than most fantasy — and the principle transfers.
About Road to Rank 1

My public learning series about becoming a better writer of interactive fiction and audio stories — by talking to experts from games, books, audio, and narrative design.

More episodes

More from the blog