Guido Schmidt and the Part About Writing Nobody Wants to Hear

Guido Schmidt and the Part About Writing Nobody Wants to Hear

Everyone I meet is writing something. Almost nobody I meet has published something. Somewhere between those two sentences lives the least popular topic in all of writing advice: writing discipline. For this episode of Road to Rank 1 I spoke with someone who has lived both sides of that gap — and he handed me exactly the advice I didn't want to hear.

I have a plan. It's not a good plan. Let's goooo!
— Christian Mahnke, Road to Rank 1

For my mission to become a better writer, I keep talking to people who have actually shipped creative work instead of only thinking about it. This time: Guido Schmidt — design director at Rovio, former developer at Paradox, Ubisoft and Remedy, and now also a published author.

What made this call interesting is that Guido has lived both sides of the problem. He has spent more than twenty years shipping games — and in recent years he returned to writing fiction and actually published books. Which brought us straight to an uncomfortable truth.

Everyone wants to write. Very few actually publish.

Guido told me that after his first book came out, suddenly lots of people confided they were writing too. Or planning to. Or almost finished.

That felt painfully familiar.

Everyone has ideas. Everyone has a story. The real difference is whether something ever leaves your head, gets finished, and reaches other people. Writing is not only imagination. It is completion. And completion is where most writers quietly disappear — not because they ran out of talent, but because they ran out of the discipline to push one thing all the way through.

The shortcut is still not real

Naturally, I asked him for the one magical tip that would make me a bestselling writer without too much pain.

His answer was extremely inconsiderate.

There is no guarantee. No safe shortcut. But if you don't make the thing and put it into the world, it definitely won't happen.
— Guido Schmidt

Annoying. But fair. What you cannot control is whether your work hits the zeitgeist. What you can control — the only thing you can control — is whether it exists at all. That is writing discipline in one sentence: doing the controllable part, repeatedly, while accepting that the uncontrollable part stays uncontrollable.

Visibility matters more than writers like to admit

Another thing Guido confirmed for me: it is not just about writing. It is also about showing up consistently around the work.

He has been posting about his books for years — and by now, people know him as "the guy with the book". That matters. Before success can scale, people first need a simple hook for who you are and what you do.

It's also one of the reasons I started Road to Rank 1 in the first place. I don't want to learn in silence and maybe emerge years later, blinking, with a manuscript. I want to build in public — this series is me applying the advice while collecting it.

Story makes ideas easier to remember

We also talked about Guido's book Game Design: Impossible, and I immediately liked its structure. Instead of writing pure theory about team dynamics, conflict and communication in game development, he wrapped those ideas in story: characters, situations, failure, analysis — and back into the story.

That's a strong reminder for anyone writing to teach: even when the goal is knowledge, story is what makes it stick. If a design director with twenty years of practice reaches for narrative to carry his hardest lessons, the rest of us can stop treating story as decoration.

What I'm taking from this one

This call was less about narrative theory and more about discipline.

Write the thing.
Finish the thing.
Publish the thing.
Repeat.

Not romantic. Probably true. Still no magical shortcut — very disappointing — but definitely another solid silver tip for the pile.

Writing discipline
What Guido Schmidt actually said
  1. The difference between writers and would-be writers isn't ideas — it's finishing and publishing.
  2. There is no shortcut. You can't control the zeitgeist; you can control whether the work exists.
  3. Show up around your work consistently — people need a simple hook for who you are before anything scales.
  4. Even when you're teaching, wrap the ideas in story. That's what makes them stick.

Guido's books and channels are collected on his Linktree.

About Road to Rank 1

My public learning series about becoming a better writer of interactive fiction and audio stories — by talking to experts from games, books, audio, and narrative design.

More episodes

More from the blog